Advanced search
Visit
6542
Last Updated: 2011/05/22
Summary of question
How can the incoherence between verses 21 of chapter 57 and 133 of chapter 3 be resolved in regards to heaven?
question
Please elaborate on the following: There is a real paradox in the Quranic description of the width and breadth of Paradise. The holy Quran says in verse 133 of chapter 3 that the width of Paradise equals the width of the whole of the heavens and of the earth whereas according to verse 21 of chapter 57, the width of Paradise is that of the width of the earth and the heaven (singular). It is clear that one heaven or one firmament does not equal many heavens or many firmaments. Hence, the width of Paradise cannot be that of the earth and the heaven and of the earth and the heavens (plural) at the same time. Therefore, we see a clear contradiction between the two verses in the Holy Quran. Verse 133 of chapter 3 says: “And hasten to forgiveness from your Lord and a Garden the width of which is as the heavens and the earth it is prepared for those who guard (against the evil)”. Else where in chapter 57, verse 21, it says: “Hasten to forgiveness from your Lord and to a garden the width of which is as the width of the heaven and the earth, it is prepared for those who believe in Allah and his messengers, that is the grace of Allah he gives it to whom He pleases, and Allah is the Lord of Mighty Grace”. These two verses are contradictory.
Concise answer

Presumably, the point which caused you to imagine that these two verses are incoherent and contradictory with each other was the translation of the word of “al-Samā” into “one heaven” whereas the real meaning of the word is “heaven” not “one heaven”. Even in the English translation of the word "al-Samā" which literally means "sky", there is no incoherence between the word “sky” and “skies”. For example, when a person says, “I saw cloud in the sky” or “I saw clouds in the skies”, both are conveying the same meaning; neither “cloud” is in contradiction with “clouds” nor is “heaven” with “heavens”. There is no incongruity between the singular and plural forms.

Detailed Answer

In order to reply to your question we should first know that the two sentences are evaluated as being contradictory with each other only when they meet all the conditions of a contradiction. For example if a person says “I offer my prayers in the mosque” and again he says “I attend congregational prayers held in several mosques", we cannot describe the two sentences as being contradictory with each other simply because he has used the singular form of a word in one sentence and the plural form in another.

Likewise, if we look carefully at the usages of the words in Arabic language, especially in the holy Quran, we will come to know that the Arabic word "al-Samā"   which means “heaven”, is not so much different from “al-Samawāt” (heavens), because the word  "al-Samā" does not mean "one heaven" otherwise it would have been in contrast with "al-Samawāt" (heavens). So the word "al-Samā" used in many different verses of the Quran implies the same meaning. For example when God, the Glorified, says in Holy Quran, "Wa maa khalaqna al-Sama wal ardha wa ma bainahoma batila"[1], it means "And We did not create the heaven and the earth and what is between them in vain". According to your translation, the meaning should be: We did not create “one heaven and the earth and what is between them in vain” (which implies that creating the other heavens should have been in vain!!).

Similarly, the verse "ma yakhfa 'alallahi min shay'in fil ardh-e wa la fis-Sama"[2] would be translated as such: “and nothing in the earth nor any thing in one heaven is hidden from Allah" which, by extension, means that He may not know what happens in the other heavens. Obviously, nobody, who is at home in Arabic, will accept such a translation.

Be sure that the word "al-Samā" in verse 21 of Chapter al-Hadid does not mean “one heaven” to be in contradiction with "al-Samawāt" in verse 133 of Chapter Aal-e Imran; they are congruous with each other. On many occasions, when the Holy Quran wants to mention a point in regards to some heavens, not all of them, it does not use the word "al-Samā" alone; rather the terms such as "al-Sama al-dunya[3]  (the lower heaven), or "kollu sama"[4] (every heaven) have been used.

Of course, if it had been said, “Hasten to Paradise whose breadth is that of the lower sky”, it would imply incoherence with other verses which say that the width and breadth of the Paradise is that of the whole of the heavens but there is not any verse like this in the Quran.

All praise is due to Allah, the Lord of the worlds.



[1] - Sād: 27 و ما خلقنا السماء و الأرض و ما بینهما باطلا

[2] -Ibrahim: 38 ما یخفی علی الله من شیء فی الارض و لا فی السماء

[3] - Safaat: 7; Fussilat: 12: Malak: 5

[4] - Fussilat: 12

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • What is the Islamic law regarding cleaning Turbah of Imam Hussein (a.s.) when it turns dark?
    10380 دو سجده 2013/05/15
    Based on the sayings of Ahlul-Bayt (a.s.), the soil of Karbala and the Turbah which is associated with the Chief of Martyrs, Imam Hussein (a.s.) enjoys a special significance. Sajda on this soil has been highly recommended by Infallible Imams (a.s.). For information in this regard, you ...
  • What is khums and what is it paid on?
    7890 آنچه خمس بدان تعلق می گیرد 2012/12/16
    Khums literally means “one-fifth or 20%”. In Islamic legal terminology, it means “one-fifth of certain items which a person earns by means of trade, industry, agricultural work, research or any other ways of earning, like, if he earns some money by working in a government department, and ...
  • Can ordinary human beings be infallible or not?
    8620 Traditional 2010/12/21
    The word infallible (ma’sum) means protection, to be secured, safety from committing sins and forgetfulness. Infallibility has levels and stages from which the highest is reserved for Prophets and imams. According to the Qur’an and traditions it is specific just for them due to their roles as leaders ...
  • What acts eliminate major sins?
    7600 Practical 2011/11/21
    The sins that people commit are not all alike in terms of their greatness and the forgiveness of different sins depends on the kind of sin that has been committed. Some sins can be forgiven by only saying astaghfurullah once while others may require more effort. We must ...
  • What is the scientific reasoning behind the splitting of the moon?
    16380 Exegesis 2009/06/22
    Considering the research and discoveries of space scientists, the answer to your question isn't very hard, because discoveries today tell us that not only isn't such a phenomenon possible, but it also actually has taken place various times regarding celestial bodies other than the moon.NASA has confirmed the ...
  • Do Shia Muslims not go to Hell?
    17327 جبر یا اختیار و عدالت پروردگار 2012/08/04
    The fact that some people are held responsible for their deeds and subjected to punishment in Hell and some are endowed with blessings and bounties is based on a principle which Allah has pointed out in some of the Quranic verses. God, the Almighty, rejects all kinds ...
  • Which animals and insects have been named in the Quran?
    59289 Exegesis 2009/12/16
    Approximately 35 animals have been named in the Quran; the birds and insects of which are:Salwa (سلوی)=The quail (Baqarah:57), Ba’uth (بعوض)=Mosquito (Baqarah:26), Dhubab (ذباب)=Fly (Hajj:73), Nahl (نحل)=Honeybee (Nahl:68), Ankabut (عنکبوت)=Spider (Ankabut:41), Jarad (جراد)=Grasshopper (A’raf:133), HudHud (هدهد)=Hoopoe (Naml:20), Ghurab (غراب)=Crow (Ma’idah:31), Ababil (ابابیل)= probably ‘Swallow’ (Fil:3), Naml (نمل)=Ant ...
  • Is it true that one shouldn’t pray for oneself on Ashura?
    5785 Practical 2011/04/20
    Dua and supplication are the needful connection between the servant and his Lord for the fulfillment of worldly and otherworldly needs. Dua for oneself and others is always something good and entails great blessings.Praying for oneself on Ashura is okay, as ...
  • What do you suggest for mut’ah to be practiced more in society?
    9473 Practical 2009/09/23
    This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer. ...
  • Is it permissible to trade wild animals to be used for a zoo or for other entertainments?
    5851 نگهداری و شکار حیوانات 2012/05/02
    Such matters have something to do with the law of the country or place where you are living. If there is no legal restriction in this regard and there is also a rational benefit in trading wild animals, there would be no problem. Appendices: ...

Popular