Visit
734
Last Updated:2008/08/28
Summary of question
Why do some people oppose mysticism and the mystics making reference to ahadith (traditions)?
question
Recently we see an overt propagation going on in some religious websites and weblogs against mysticism and the mystics. In these websites, prominent figures like Allamah Tabatabai, Hasan Zadeh Amuli, Mulla Sadra, Hafiz Shirazi and Rumi Balkhi are openly insulted and derogatory words are used against them. As they claim, they are using traditions and narrations in their websites to denounce the mystics. Kindly, guide me in this regard.
Concise answer

Irfan (mysticism/ Gnosticism) has been defined as a special method to reach the realities of existence and to connect man to truth, which is done through vision and intuition. Such an understanding depends on practice and special asceticism. The practical methods or what is known as ‘wayfaring method’ is also called irfan. A real Gnostic (‘arif) is one who, by implementing certain programs and austerity measures, attain intuitive knowledge or knowledge by presence in respect of God, His attributes and actions.

When it comes to various approaches regarding irfan, some have categorically denied the existence of irfan in Islam saying that it is an unacceptable innovation and the Gnostics are misguided and deviated people. Some others have believed in something in the name of irfan which cannot be considered to have originated in religious texts i.e. the Book and the Sunnah. In fact, some of their beliefs are clearly opposed to explicit religious texts and they are not in any way interpretable. As well, practically talking, they have on the one hand created certain etiquettes and norms for themselves or borrowed these from non-Islamic sects. On the other hand, they believe that a mystic or Gnostic who has attained the truth is relieved of obligation.

The fact is that the opponents of irfan have no concrete and reliable arguments to prove their point of view whereas irfan is a part and parcel of Islam. It is the heart and soul of Islam emanating, like all other parts of Islam, from the Holy Quran and prophetic traditions. That is to say, spiritual and mystical wayfaring is not an independent path alongside Shari’ah. In reality, it is the interior and the esoteric aspect of the Shari’ah. In other words, Shari’ah explains the apparent rules and irfan is tasked to discover and unveil the wisdom, secrets and reality of Shari’ah laws. There is no doubt that what is called irfan is not necessarily ratified and approved of by Islam because there are pseudo versions of irfan which have nothing to do with real irfan. The real irfan has certain features and characteristics which will be discussed in its appropriate place.

Detailed Answer

The word irfan literally means ‘knowing’ and irfan in the technical meaning refers to a special method to reach the realities of existence and to connect man to truth, which is done through vision, intuition, attainment and unifying with the truth. Since intuitive knowledge depends normally on special rehearsals and ascetic measures, the practical methods or what is known as ‘wayfaring method’ is also called irfan.

Having said that, it is now clear that a real Gnostic (Arif) is one who, by implementing certain programs and austerity measures, attain intuitive knowledge or knowledge by presence in respect of God, His attributes and actions.

What has, in fact, caused discrepancies about the validity and invalidity; rightness and wrongness of irfan and the wayfaring methods of the gnostics is the answer which everybody has given to the following question: “Is there anything in the name of Islamic irfan (Islamic mysticism) in Islam or is it Muslims who have taken and imported it from others?

In reply to this question, some have categorically denied the existence of irfan in Islam saying that it is an unacceptable innovation and the Gnostics are misguided and deviated people. Some others have believed in something in the name of irfan which cannot be considered to have originated in religious texts i.e. the Book and the Sunnah.

One who goes carefully through the verses of the Quran and sayings of the Prophet (S) and the Ahlul-Bait (A.S.), he will definitely find highly profound materials and guidelines in irfan or information about etiquettes and guidelines in connection with mystical wayfaring. For example, we can refer to the verses concerning the oneness of God, His attributes and actions in chapter al-Tawhid, the beginning of chapter al-Hadid, the end of chapter al-Hashr and also to the verses regarding divine omnipotence, the power of God and creatures which praise and glorify Him.

Also, there are verses referring to special etiquettes and manners which we can call the Islamic manners of wayfaring such as verses on contemplation and meditation, permanent remembrance and attention, staying awake before dawn, fasting, prostration and lingering glorification at night, humility and submissiveness, crying, sincerity in the acts of worship, doing good deeds out of love and devotion to God with the purpose of seeking nearness to God and achieving divine pleasure. Also, there are verses concerning tawakkol (consigning one’s matters to Allah), divine pleasure and submission to God. There are uncountable traditions from the Holy Prophet (S) and the infallible Imams in this regard plus supplications and invocations which are replete with mystical contents.

There are people who seeing these verses and sayings from the Prophet (S) and the Ahlul-Bayt (A.S.) have gone to the two sides of an extreme: The first group has a narrow-minded approach judging everything on its appearance and depleting the verses and narrations from the lofty and profound meanings. These are people who generally deny the existence of anything in the name of “irfan” in the Islamic texts.

Another group of people has believed in something in the name of irfan which cannot be considered to have originated in religious texts i.e. the Book and the Sunnah. In fact, some of their beliefs are clearly opposed to explicit religious texts and they are not in any way interpretable. As well, practically talking, they have on the one hand created certain etiquettes and norms for themselves or borrowed these from non-Islamic sects. On the other hand, they believe that a mystic or Gnostic who has attained the truth is relieved of obligation.

A third group which has protected itself against the two sides of the extreme is of the view that mystical wayfaring is not an independent path alongside Shari’ah. In reality, it is the more delicate and subtle part of the Shari’ah. If we confine the term “Shari’ah” to the apparent rules, we must say that tariqat (pathway) constitutes the interior and esoteric aspect of the Shari’ah. For example, Shari’ah determines the evident prayer-related rules of prayer but irfan is bound to find ways of concentration in it.[1] It should be noted that what is called irfan is not necessarily ratified and approved of by Islam because there are pseudo versions of irfan which have nothing to do with real irfan. The real irfan has certain features and indicators which will be discussed in its appropriate place.

For further information about Islamic mysticism and its features refer to Balagh website and to questions 1223 (site: 1220), 239 (site: 1780) and 924 (site: 1490).

 


[1] - A summary of an article by Mesbah, Muhammad Taqi, Ma’refat Periodical, No. 21, Mysticism and Islamic Philosophy

 

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Random questions

  • Can anyone other than Allah (swt) be aware of the unseen?
    1048 Modern 2009/09/07
    Gheyb means for something to be hidden from one’s senses, and shahadah means openness and visibility.One thing can be gheyb for a person, while being shahadah for another. It depends on the individual’s existential boundaries and how much of the existential world they cover and encompass in knowledge. But keeping ...
  • What is the ruling on child custody in the absence of the father?
    636 Laws and Jurisprudence 2007/01/17
    Grand Ayatollah Khamenei’s responseAccording to Islamic principles, assuming a child’s father passes away, the right to having custody of the child is, also, awarded to the mother up until the child attains the age of puberty. On occasions where the father is absent [for any given reason], such an absence ...
  • Is God subjugated to natural laws?
    632 Traditional 2012/03/10
    Allah is the one who has set all natural laws, and the only thing He is under the influence of, is His own will. The one thing to keep in mind is that His will is that things take place through their natural causes. In addition to the fact that ...
  • Can reading the Quran’s translation be beneficial?
    765 Quranic Studies 2010/08/01
    From a fiqhi perspective, reading the Quran’s translation doesn’t count as the recitation of the Quran itself and it is for this reason that the ulema have stated: “Touching the writing of the Quran with any part of the body is haram for one who doesn’t have wudu. But if ...
  • What do you mean by religious thought?
    888 Traditional 2006/07/15
    By “religious thought” we mean that form of thought which is concerned whit any of the problems of a religious nature within a particular religion, in the same sense that mathematical thought is the form of thought which deals with mathematical questions and solves mathematical problems. ...
  • Why does Allah hate divorce so much?
    989 Philosophy of Religion and Law 2012/02/15
    Considering the antithesis between divorce and marriage, in order to learn of the reason why Allah hates divorce so much, we must first see why marriage bears so much significance in His eyes.[1]In the Quran, the creation of people in pairs has been mentioned as one of Allah’s signs, which ...
  • Were miracles performed by prophets in order to demonstrate the truth of their claims to prophethood or were they to meet the demands of stubborn people? What is meant by “We made from water every living thing”?
    22 Exegesis 2013/05/19
    1. It is necessary to note that bringing a miracle is a decisive and clear proof of the authenticity of a prophet’s claim to prophethood. It is not, therefore, just to convince people.[1] 2. The verses mentioned in your message speak of stubborn people who are never ready to surrender to ...
  • What would have happened if the Caliphate had fallen into the hands of Imam Ali (as)?
    730 Traditional 2011/05/18
    Certainly, Imam Ali’s (as) greatest concern would have been to continue the way of the Holy Prophet (saw) and guard the path of hidayah (guidance) and true Islam, so that mankind could reach sa’adah (salvation) both in this world and the next. The Holy Prophet of Islam (saw) has referred ...
  • What is the ruling on shaving the beard and body hair?
    866 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/01/17
    Only shaving or trimming facial hair (beard)[1] with shaving machines in a way that people say there is no beard anymore, is impermissible based on obligatory precaution.[2] Also, shaving a portion of the beard has the same ruling as shaving all of it.[3] Thus, shaving the hairs on the cheeks ...
  • What relationship do the believers have with the Quran during the Presence of a Masoom?
    1178 Traditional 2007/01/01
                The Quran is the word of God, and it is a book for studying, understanding, and acting in accordance with, in order for mankind to maintain a prosperous life. However, the comprehension and meaning of all of the ayats are not the same. Some verses are easy to comprehend, ...

Popular

  • What is Islam’s view on dinosaurs?
    7403 Exegesis 2007/02/26
                The Quran is a book of guidance and everything which supports this goal [of guidance] has been mentioned in this Holy Book. The method used in expressing matters is: focusing on the general aspects and less on the details and particulars, and the reason for that may be the ...
  • What are the signs of the reappearance of Imam Mahdi (atf) and the events that shall take place thereupon?
    6374 Traditional 2012/01/28
    Your question concerning the reappearance of the Imam of Time can be investigated around four focal points:First: The signs for his coming are categorized into different groups, one of them being their classification into “certain” and “uncertain” signs: According to some hadiths, five signs are considered “certain” and they are ...
  • What is meant by Sidratul-Muntaha that the Quran has mentioned?
    3946 Exegesis 2010/04/07
    This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer. ...
  • What is a muslims duty when dealing with atheist?
    3433 Quran 2006/10/09
    Dear Brother/Sister,Assalam alaikum wa rahmatullah.The answer to your question is as follows: As a believer you should try to show others the beauty of religion and its dimensions in order to motivate them into learning about religion and to have a positive inclination towards it. For example, you can demonstrate ...
  • I have researched that before the creation of Hazrat Adam there were jins on earth...
    3424 Traditional 2007/04/11
    The existence of jins is established in the Quran and there characteristics are also displayed. Even though our knowledge about jins is limited and minute, there are many proofs that one can use proving that there were jin prophets before the creation of Prophet Adam (a). Some of the proofs ...
  • Why was Hazrat Muhammad (P.B.U.H.) allowed to have more than four wives?
    3110 Philosophy of Religion and Law 2007/04/05
    The topic of the prophet of Islam’s (P.B.U.H.) marriages and number of spouses is a subject which has been questioned very much. In reference to this issue, we should mention first of all that before the ruling for the impermissibility of having more than four wives was revealed, Hazrat Muhammad ...
  • How should an astronaut get wudhu and make prayer in outer space?
    2971 Modern 2006/11/26
                Under no circumstances or conditions is it permissible to discard obligatory prayers, and they must be made in any possible situation. If possible, a person who is in space or on a spaceship should try to settle in a fixed location using the available means in order to complete ...
  • I would like to know the methods of religious thought.
    2955 Traditional 2006/07/15
    There are three methods of religious thought in Islam. The Holy Quran in its teachings points to three paths for Muslims to follow in order to comprehend the purposes of religion and the Islamic sciences: (1) the path of the external and formal aspect of religion (the ...
  • If a woman is divorced and then remarries, then who would be her spouse in the hereafter?
    2826 Traditional 2006/12/02
                For a man and a woman who were married to each other in this world, there a several theories regarding their situation in the next world; for example:  The husband and the wife are both in heaven.The wife is in heaven and the husband in hell.The husband is in ...
  • Why is it permitted for a married man to have a temporary wife, without his wife's approval?
    2242 Modern 2007/09/26
    Sexual inclinations are one of the strongest human instincts which, like other natural human instincts, must be satisfied in the appropriate way. Human instincts can not be extinguished and even if we can suppress them it is not wise to do so, as that would be fighting against the laws ...

Links