Advanced search
Last Updated: 2008/09/21
Summary of question
Why is the grave of Lady Fatimah (as) still concealed, while Imam Ali’s (as) has been revealed?
Considering the enmity towards Imam Ali (as) and Lady Fatimah (as), why has Imam Ali’s (as) grave been revealed after some time, while Lady Fatimah’s (as) is still missing?
Concise answer

The reason for why the grave of Imam Ali (as) was concealed for a while was the fact that ignorant and abusive individuals who were enemies to him, would possibly disrespect his grave. Later on though, after time had passed and the abovementioned individuals had passed away, in addition to the growing strength of the school and teachings of the Ahlul-Bayt, the possibilities of such a matter lessened. Moreover, since the grave was located in between reeds and the desert, no one was certain even about its approximate whereabouts, causing the people not to be able to visit it and from its great blessings and bounties. These factors caused the imams to show the grave to their true followers and slowly, it became known to all over the years and as the Shia became stronger.

As for why Lady Fatimah (as) had ordered for her grave to be concealed, it was because this was a form of protest and making her voice heard that she objects to what has taken place regarding the caliphate and successorship of the Prophet (pbuh).[1] Therefore, as long as the Muslim nation doesn’t believe in what she believes in regarding the Prophet’s successorship, which results in the deprivation of the Muslim nation of many true Islamic teachings, the reason for the concealment of her grave will remain.

Another point is that the concealment of her grave is a strong barrier that doesn’t allow the falsification of the history of early Islam, preventing people from totally denying her stance against the situation that had come up regarding the caliphate. The issue of her grave is a sign for those in search of the truth, guiding them across the sea of evil and corruption to the shore of salvation, unveiling the truth and completing Allah’s (swt) proof regarding it.

Of course, since the approximate coordinates of her grave have been mentioned[2], people can benefit from the areas close to her grave.

What was said, were only a few points that are supported by different clues and evidence, but that doesn’t mean that these are all of the reasons, meaning that there are possibilities that there are other secrets behind this matter that might be unveiled in the future.

[1] See: Ibn Abil-Hadid, Sharh Nahjul-Balaghah, vol.16, pg.281; Sheykh Abdullah Naser, Mihnatu Fatimah ba’da Wafati Rasulillah, pp.197-206.

[2] According to hadiths, some of the places that her grave might possible be located are: between the Minbar and Mihrab of Masjidul-Nabi, Lady Fatimah’s (as) home, and the graveyard of Baqi’.

Question translations in other languages
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Categorization by subject

Random questions

  • What is absolute existence? What is indeterminate existence?
    1745 Islamic Philosophy 2011/12/20
    Absolute existence has different meanings and usages; sometimes it means ‘unconditional’; that there is no condition limiting it, not even the condition of absoluteness (one of its conditions isn't absoluteness). Sometimes, this isn't the case, and although it is absolute, it is still limited to the condition of absoluteness (one ...
  • Is it permissible to serve alcoholic beverages in restaurants in the west?
    1459 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/06/21
    The dignity of Muslims around the world depends on their adherence to their religion’s laws and devotement to Islam, and they must strive to remain committed to the pact they have made with Allah (swt).Some of the maraje’ have stated that if it is possible, one must change his/her job, ...
  • What is the Islamic law about taking off one's shirt and beating the chest in mourning for Imam Hussein (a)?
    1145 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/08/06
    What has been mentioned in the fatwa of most of the grand jurists about taking off one's shirts and beating the chest indicate that it is permissible to take off one's shirts, if it is not in front of non-mahram (women) and if it does not entail any corruption. None ...
  • Does man have the capacity to love Allah?
    1503 Practical 2010/09/05
    The logic behind experiencing ‘metaphoric’ love is to reach true love and if it is accompanied with chastity, after causing fundamental changes and developments it will bring man very close to Godly love. The very core and truth of religion is to reach the status of loving Allah; Islam especially ...
  • What does Islam say about Prophet Isa (pbuh) walking on water?
    2579 Traditional 2009/07/19
    One of the ways for identifying prophets is through miracles; extraordinary actions that can't be taught or learned by normal people that others aren't capable of doing.[1]Prophet Isa (pbuh) had several miracles, namely: awakening the dead, curing those born blind and curing the sick. The Quran says: “…and when You ...
  • What is Islam’s viewpoint on cloning?
    2206 Laws and Jurisprudence 2008/05/12
    Cloning and especially the cloning of humans is a new subject that has come up in our era and as a result, its ruling hasn’t been mentioned in the Quran and Islamic tradition, yet Shia scholars and jurisprudents have been able to reach certain conclusions on it using ijtihad (Islamic ...
  • What is the Islamic law about carrying the Quran throughout the day or when one is entering a toilet?
    1310 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/11/21
    There is no problem in carrying the Quran. However, there are certain points which you should keep in mind: 1. It is makrooh (abominable) to carry the Quran in the state of Janabat[1] and Hayz (menses)[2]. 2. If one wishes to touch the lines of the Quran or make a ...
  • What does Islam say about sound relationships between boys and girls?
    3210 Laws and Jurisprudence 2012/04/21
    According to Islam, the male and female complement each other and God, the All-Kind, has created them fore each other. One of the needs they have, are sexual ones. Fulfilling these needs must be within the boundaries and guidelines of Islam so that chastity and modesty are not compromised. According to ...
  • What will Prophet Isa’s (pbuh) role be during the return of Imam Mahdi (aj)?
    2059 Modern 2009/09/23
    This question doesn’t have a brief answer. Please click on the detailed answer. ...
  • What is the relationship between the soul and body?
    2305 Islamic Philosophy 2009/12/28
    Regarding the link and relationship between the soul and body, one must say that the body is one of the several degrees of the soul and spirit, resulting in the body being located in the soul and spirit, not the spirit and soul being trapped in the body, the reason ...