Advanced search
Visit
8746
Last Updated: 2012/03/08
Summary of question
Why are Iranian ceremonies for holidays and for mourning different from Muslim and Shi’a ones?
question
Why are Iranian ceremonies for holidays and for mourning different from Muslim and Shi’a ones?
Concise answer

Even though ceremonies that are held for religious occasions must be in accordance with the general guidelines of Islam, but in regard to the details about which Islam has not mentioned guidelines, the ceremonies should be carried out accordanceing to the dominant culture of people and their customs. In other words, what has been encouraged in Islam is mourning for Imam Hussein, but the method of doing so may be decided by the people. This is why these ceremonies are held in different ways and methods depending on the place they are held in, and the only limitation is the violation of Islam’s general rulings in this regard.

Detailed Answer

Different ceremonies are held in different religions to honor their values, occasions and beliefs. Similarly, such ceremonies are held in Islam, especially amongst Shias. In the Quran, God has commanded that his sacraments be honored and venerated and states that this act stems from one’s Taqwa: “And whoever venerates the sacraments of Allah indeed that arises from the God wariness of hearts.”[1]

Therefore, holding these ceremonies has been encouraged in our religion. It is clear that each and every nation its own special way of holding and carrying out these ceremonies depending on their culture and customs. As long as these cultures and customs do not contradict Islamic rulings, they are accepted from Islam’s point of view. For example, holding gatherings of mourning for Imam Hussein, crying and making others cry for the Imam are all among acts greatly encouraged by the Prophet and the Imams.[2] However, the method of mourning and honoring Imam Hussein may differ in different countries. Even within Iran the forms of mourning are different in its many cities, as each city has its special method. The primary goal of such gatherings should be honoring the Imam and mourning for him and these gatherings should also be in accordance with Islamic teachings and guidelines. Since many years ago, it has been customary in Iran for people to hold gatherings and take to the streets in groups and mourn in public. This method has always been endorsed by the scholars of religion. In this regard, Imam Khomeini has said: “We must protect and maintain these Islamic customs. We must maintain the Dastes (groups that take to the streets and mourn in public). We must emphasize on these customs that are carried out during the months of Muharram and Safar so that they are perpetually performed.”[3] Sheikh Tusi narrates a hadith from Imam Sadiq that illustrates how the women of the Prophet’s progeny would mourn during his time. In this hadith, the Imam says: “The female descendants of Lady Fatimah, in these gatherings, would tear their clothes and slap their faces [in grief].” He then endorses this method by saying: “Upon the likes of Hussain should such be done.”[4]

However, we must say that due to ignorance, certain acts have been carried out by ignorant people that contradict Islamic rulings or promote myths. The ulema have opposed these people and have made it clear that their actions are not accepted from the Islamic point of view. A good example would be the act of Ghame Zani (self flagellation) which was a means of honoring Imam Hussein in the past, but has been prohibited by many of the Maraje due to nowadays’ circumstances. At the beginning of the revolution, Imam Khomeini said: “In such circumstances (nowadays) do not perform Ghame Zani”. Also, Ayatollah Khamenei has said: “Performing Ghame Zani openly and in the public in not permissible.”[5]

In conclusion, the differences in the forms and ways of mourning for and honoring Imam Hussein -which have not been stipulated in detail by Islamic guidelines and people are free to determine by themselves- [6]stems from the difference of culture and customs, which is completely natural and acceptable.

 


[1] Hajj:32.

[2] Maqtal Muqram, pg. 96.

[3] Farhange Ashura, Muhaddithi, Javad, pg. 341, as quoted by Sahifeye Nur, vol. 15 pg. 2041.

[4] Maqtal Muqram, pg. 97; Tahdhib, vol. 2, pg. 283 (at the end of the discussion on kaffaraat).

[5] Farhange Ashura, pp. 386 and 387.

[6] Unlike some acts of worship such as praying about which Islam has clearly explained how they should be performed and has not allowed anyone to perform them according to their culture and customs.

 

Question translations in other languages
Comments
Number of comments 0
Please enter the value
Example : Yourname@YourDomane.ext
Please enter the value
Please enter the value

Thematic Category

Random questions

  • What is the veracity of the supplication “Allahumma kun li-waliyyik al-Hujjatibnil Hasan… and how do we know that it is authentic?
    12403 Contextual study 2017/05/22
    This holy supplication has been reported with some variation in different Shia sources including the book of Al-Kafi. It is good to recite this dua for the wellbeing of Imam of Time, may Allah hasten his reappearance. Generally speaking, the different parts of this dua indicate the ...
  • Is it true that every human being has a twin or an associate?
    11775 Contextual study 2015/06/09
    As for whether human beings have twins or not, there are a few narrations. It has been reported that God, the Exalted, told Iblis: I will not give Adam a child except that I will give the like of it to you. Every human being has a ...
  • Was the Prophet of Islam (S) a prophet at birth?
    7536 وحی، نبوت و عصمت 2018/10/22
    The prophethood of the Prophet of Islam (S) can be considered as having two aspects: 1. The first aspect of prophethood is tantamount to prophetic mission and the beginning of a procedure which involved promulgation and propagation of the religion as well as the establishment of the ...
  • Is it possible to see God? If so, then how?
    9594 Traditional 2010/04/08
    According to both Islamic sources and the intellect, God cannot be seen by the physical eye neither in this life nor in the next. However He can be seen through the eyes of the heart. Up to each given individual’s capacity, after purifying their souls, and engaging in prayers and ...
  • What is the Islamic law about pictures ascribed to the Imams (a.s.)?
    9563 Laws and Jurisprudence 2011/10/29
    What follows are answers given to the above question by the religious authorities (grand jurists):Grand Ayatollah Khamenei (may Allah grant him long life): As per the Islamic law, there is no problem in it by itself provided that it is ...
  • What is the Maqam Ibrahim? What is its purpose?
    41598 Traditional 2010/02/14
    One of the clear signs in Makkah (as a verse in the Quran tells us) is the Maqam Ibrahim where Prophet Ibrahim stood.Regarding the meaning and interpretation of “Maqam Ibrahim”, some believe that it is equal to all of Hajj. Others ...
  • Are the punishments for some sins harsher and greater by many folds than the punishments for some other sins?
    7273 Theoretical 2012/01/04
    It is inferred from the Holy Qur'an and traditions of the Ahlul-Bayt (a.s.) that there are different degrees of torments in hell, proportioned to the different degrees of sins on earth. The Quran considers associating partners with God (shirk) as the greatest sin. Also, God warns to punish the sinners ...
  • Why does the verdict of a marja become invalid after his death?
    8184 Philosophy of Religion and Law 2007/04/08
    It must be known that ijtihad has different elements: some are firm (ex. Quran, prophetic traditions, intellect…) and others are changeable (ex. Subjects and their conditions, knowledge and the understanding of the marja himself). A mujtahid must always be aware of the changeable elements. Hence, it ...
  • What is Islam’s ruling on listening to music?
    14879 Laws and Jurisprudence 2010/11/21
    Music is essentially sound, and watching it (without listening) has no ruling; the only ruling there is, has to do with producing and the sale of instruments, teaching and learning, playing, and listening to it. Most scholars consider listening to and producing lahwi music to be haram and ...
  • How come although all of us gave an oath in the Alame-Arwah, there are still people who have religions other than Islam?
    30866 Traditional 2009/03/14
    In our religious texts and scriptures, a realm or world by the name of Dharr has been spoken of. There are differences between the scholars regarding what this realm exactly is. Nevertheless, the viewpoint which seems to be the best of all is the one that says Allah ...

Popular